The 6 Best Wet Cat Food Brands with Ratings & Reviews for 2018
These healthy, biologically-appropriate options will give your kitty the best chance of a long, happy, and healthy life
There’s no question that wet food is the best option for cats. There are way more healthy wet foods than there are dry foods out there.
Even so, that doesn’t mean that all wet foods are healthy. Quite the opposite!
While it’s easier to make a soft food that will keep your kitty fit throughout her life, many companies still pack fillers and potentially harmful ingredients into their recipes, just to make a quick buck.
Meat is an expensive ingredient, after all!
But meat is what cats want - and need - to eat to stay healthy.
Through exhaustive research and the creation of our database of over 2000+ cat foods, we narrowed it down to these 6 top rated options.
The 6 Best Wet Foods for Cats
- NomNomNow - Near-perfect macronutrient profile. Fresh made. Delivered. (EDITOR'S CHOICE)
- Bravo! Feline Cafe - Great variety of meat (including organs). No carbs. Great value.
- Crave Grain-Free - Good variety of organ meats. No carbs.
- Feline Natural Grain-Free - Healthy mix of common and novelty proteins (including organs). No gums/thickeners.
- Nutro Chunky Loaf Adult - Great nutrient profile for cats. No carbs.
- Tiki Cat After Dark - High protein. Good mix of meats and organs. No fillers.
How To Choose The Best Wet Food For Your Kitty
Food is the number one way to keep your cat happy, healthy, and long living.
Just like for humans, food is the fuel that keeps your cat going.
If you fill her up with cheap food stuffed with carbs, fillers, and other junk, you shouldn't be surprised when she's slow, lazy, lethargic, has a dull coat, and eventually gets sick.
But what does your cat's body need to thrive? What's the "high octane" gas she needs in her system to live a healthy life by your side for years?
Cats are carnivores.
Carnivores need meat and moist food.
(Cat's have a really poor thirst drive...they never drink enough water. That's because in the wild, they get most of their water from the prey they eat. Most meat is 60-70% moisture!)
Your kitty's body is designed to function on only a few meat-based ingredients.
Lots of ingredients used in commercial cat food today can make your cat sick. (I'd be happy to send you our list of the 15 worst cat food ingredients, just click here and leave me your email and I'll send it over).
The best foods are those that are packed full of meat (including organ meat), and have about 50% of their calories coming from protein and 50% coming from fats.
A few carbs are OK but no more than 5-10%.
This is just the REALLY quick version of what makes a cat food GREAT, but it should help you see why we picked what we picked below in our list...out of the 2000+ options we've researched.
If you want to learn more about our process and about feline dietary needs, we'll explain it in greater detail below our reviews, but if you just want the best of the best for your cat, check out our ratings right here:
|VIEW BEST PRICE|
|VIEW BEST PRICE|
|VIEW BEST PRICE|
|VIEW BEST PRICE|
|VIEW BEST PRICE|
|VIEW BEST PRICE|
Reviews Of The 6 Best Wet Cat Foods
#1. NomNomNow Fresh Wet Cat Food (EDITOR'S CHOICE)
Macronutrients on a caloric basis:
- Protein: 60.2%
- Fat: 32.5%
- Carbs: 7.4%
First 4 ingredients: Chicken thigh, chicken breast, chicken liver, carrot
Recall info: Never been recalled
Cost/week for a 10 lb cat: $22.44
NomNomNow gives your cat all the benefits of a "wild" or homemade meal...with NONE of the hassle.
And yes, a "wild" or homemade meal is THE BEST thing for your cat.
Multiple studies have been done proving what cats want and need to eat.
But let's face it: nobody is going to let a bunch of mice loose in their house just to give their cat a "wild" diet!
And making your own cat food is ridiculously difficult and time consuming...
...and if you get it wrong, the results can be deadly.
With a variety of different cuts of meat, including organ meat, NomNomNow closely mimics the perfect diet for cats - the one they eat in the wild.
And the macronutrient profile backs it up, giving tons of protein and lots of healthy fats.
It helps that each recipe is designed by one of the few board-certified veterinary nutritionists in the country!
That means this is designed to keep any cat happy, healthy, and alive for a long time.
Not only is it a good food, but the service you get is phenomenal.
You see, it's not your typical canned food...
NomNomNow makes fresh, handmade food in their own FDA-compliant kitchen, which is located in the USA.
They portion out the perfect amount for your cat to eat every day.
Then they send you the meals right to your front door, in a special box that keeps the food cool with ice packs.
This is legitimately human grade food (there's actually a funny video of their founders eating the food that they make!).
It's super healthy.
It's incredibly convenient.
It's totally fresh.
It's what your cat wants and we think it's the best food you can feed your fur baby.
- As good as "wild" or homemade
- Lots of protein
- Fresh made, in a US-based kitchen
- Perfectly portioned meals in individual packages
- Delivered to your door for maximum convenience
- Not many recipes
- Need some space in your freezer to store food
What we especially love about Bravo! is that it contains such a wide and impressive variety of meats.
In the chicken recipe, for example, you get chicken, chicken broth, chicken heart, chicken liver, and chicken gizzards.
In the wild, cats thrive on organ meats, so it's very exciting to see a food that is packed full of them!
Muscle meat alone is NOT enough for your cat.
In fact, it's one of the major errors that people make when they try to feed a homemade diet.
Here in North America, most of us aren't fans of eating organ meat, so we don't even think of it when it comes time to feed our cats. Organ meat is just...gross, right?
But if you feed your cat only "muscle meat" like chicken breasts, they're missing out on a ton of vital micronutrients like vitamins and minerals.
And vets are seeing cats come in on their death bed, simply because they aren't getting the vitamins and minerals found in organ meat.
Bravo! continues their recipe with eggs (which are a complete protein), salmon oil, and green lipped mussels, which are vital for joint health.
From top to bottom this is a well thought out recipe that targets everything that is important to keep cats healthy.
While Bravo! has had trouble in the past with recalls, it has been years since they last went through this, and we think that the quality of this food is too good to pass up, especially since it seems they have gotten their manufacturing processes under control.
If you're looking for a reasonably priced food that is about as good as you can get health-wise, Bravo! should be your go-to.
- Great use of healthy organ meats
- One of the cheapest 5 star options available
- Includes ingredients for healthy joints
- Slightly lower protein than others
- Trouble with recalls in the past
#3. Crave Grain-Free Food Tray Chicken Cuts in Gravy
Macronutrients on a caloric basis:
- Protein: 48.7%
- Fat: 46.0%
- Carbs: 5.41%
First 4 ingredients: Chicken Broth, Chicken, Chicken Liver, Pork Plasma
Recall Info: No recalls
Cost/week for a 10 lb cat: $24.80
Crave got the message that cats love organ meat.
It includes chicken liver and heart, which are both very important cuts of meat that provide not only the protein your cat needs to stay healthy, but micronutrients like vitamin A, B vitamins, and iron.
The macronutrients (protein and fat) are among the best you'll see, since they very closely mirror what cats choose to eat in the wild.
While we don't love the tapioca starch, dried tomato, and xanthan gum in this recipe, they exist in very small amounts, and won't harm your cat.
They're probably added to help the food keep it's shape a little bit more, rather than being too "soupy".
Considering they managed to get such an amazing amount of protein and fat in there...this proves there's hardly any "filler" ingredients, and that it's suited perfectly for cats of all ages.
The unique package design allows you to quickly and easily open up a package and feed it to your cat without having to measure from a can (super convenient to just open a package and be done), though we don't love that it ends up using a lot of plastic.
Interestingly, they include pork plasma (blood) in this recipe, which is actually a really good addition.
Plasma is actually used as a gelling agent or thickener, in place of synthetic ingredients that might harm your cat.
Because it's blood, which cats would eat a lot of in the wild, it's biologically appropriate and may help your cat digest the food better.
Due to the protein and fat numbers and the mostly-great ingredients in this recipe, we highly recommend this food.
- Near-perfect macronutrient profile (proteins and fats)
- Good use of healthy organ meats
- Plasma (blood) is a good natural thickening agent, and helps digestibility
- Includes a small amount of "filler" ingredients
- Plastic packaging may create a lot of waste
#4. Feline Natural Grain-Free New Zealand Chicken & Venison
Macronutrients on a caloric basis:
- Protein: 40.1%
- Fat: 54.1%
- Carbs: 5.8%
First 4 ingredients: Chicken, Chicken Heart, Venison Kidney, Venison Liver
Recall Info: 1 recall, for their dog food
Cost/week for a 10 lb cat: $43.87
The ingredient list for this food is short.
And that's fantastic news.
It means that this food gets most of the vital nutrients that cats need (vitamins and minerals) from the actual whole-food ingredients, like chicken heart, venison kidney, venison liver, and New Zealand green mussels.
So many foods have an absolutely massive list of ingredients, including a long list of added vitamins and minerals.
While Feline Natural does include 9 additional vitamins and minerals, it's a LOT better than the 18+ that most other companies have to add.
Cats will digest and absorb the nutrients in whole food much better than added synthetic vitamins and minerals.
This recipe also includes just 8 whole food ingredients, most of which are meat (including organs, which are incredibly important for their overall well being).
That means there are absolutely NO fillers or controversial items in here.
This is the "cleanest" canned food out of all of our recommendations thanks to it's limited ingredient list.
We've already talked about the importance of organ meat, but we love the addition of mussels.
Mussels are a very high quality ingredient that only a few of the top foods use.
They're full of nutrients that help keep your kitty's joints healthy. This is especially important for senior cats.
Now, the protein and fat levels are great, but they're not perfect.
When we're looking at what cats prefer to eat (studies have shown this is true in both the wild AND in lab tests with domestic cats), we know that the ideal feline diet is about 50% protein and 50% fat.
This falls just short on the protein, while giving a little bit of extra fat.
However, it's miles ahead of most options out there, and if you're looking for a limited ingredient diet that helps strengthen your furry friend's joints, this is a great option.
- Limited, but very high quality, ingredient list
- Great use of organ meats and novelty protein (venison)
- Includes joint-health ingredients like mussels
- Slightly lower protein/higher fat compared to others on this list
Nutro is a great option that comes in on the less expensive side of things.
It's very limited ingredient, which means there's no room for fillers.
In fact, the only non-meat option at the top of the ingredient list is guar gum, which is a fairly safe (though not perfect) thickening agent.
It includes chicken and chicken liver, which are fantastic ingredients for cats.
Organ meat, like liver, is especially important, and provides not only protein but iron and vitamins.
We would like to see it include another type of meat, though, like heart or kidney, just to round out the nutrients that your cat is getting from whole foods.
Instead of using "water for processing", like most cheaper canned foods, Nutro uses chicken and pork broth.
While not packed with nutrition, they will have a little bit more nutrients than water, so it's a nice touch when brands use these ingredients.
Fish oil can help provide a shiny coat and create healthy joints.
And then it's just a variety of vitamins and minerals to make sure your cat has all she needs to be a happy, healthy kitty.
Since it has a near-perfect macronutrient profile (fats and proteins) for cats, and is fairly limited ingredient, while being fairly inexpensive, we think that this is a pretty good option.
- Near-perfect macronutrient profile (fats and proteins)
- Great value
- Limited ingredient, no carbohydrate fillers
- Includes guar gum as a thickener
- Would like to see more organ meats used
#6. Tiki Cat After Dark Chicken & Duck
Macronutrients on a caloric basis:
- Protein: 64.1%
- Fat: 31.1%
- Carbs: 4.8%
First 4 ingredients: Chicken Broth, Chicken, Chicken Liver, Chicken Gizzard
Recall Info: No recalls
Cost/week for a 10 lb cat: $48.47
Across the board, Tiki Cat probably has the best overall line of cat food.
While some companies have 2 or 3 really great recipes, and a number of average ones, Tiki Cat manages to have an entire line up of great recipes.
It's definitely on the more expensive side of things, but there are literally ZERO fillers in here.
The Chicken & Duck recipe in their After Dark series contains chicken and duck, as well as chicken liver, chicken heart, and chicken gizzards.
These are all very high quality ingredients, and it's great to see organ meat listed so prominently.
After that, it's vitamins and minerals.
And that's it.
No gelling agents, no thickeners, no added carbs.
This is a very "clean" cat food, with literally no controversial ingredients.
The protein is very high, and honestly we wouldn't mind seeing a ratio closer to 1:1 between protein and fat, but regardless, this remains an amazing pick.
Each one of the After Dark recipes scores a perfect 5/5 on our rating scale, and if you're looking for an exciting meal for a picky eater, this is probably one of your best bets.
- Limited ingredient, very clean recipe
- High protein
- Nice use of healthy organ meats
- Would like to see the protein:fat ratio be closer to 1:1
How We Rate And Review Foods
We have collected a massive database after hundreds of hours of research and analysis.
It now contains over 2000 individual foods that we have rated and reviewed.
We collected all the relevant information on each product, including:
- AAFCO Rating
- Ingredient list
- Macronutrient profiles (Guaranteed Analysis, Dry-Matter Basis, and Caloric Basis, for Protein, Fat, and Carbs)
- Whether meat is the first ingredient
- How each food compares to the average of all foods on a macronutrient basis
- Whether the recipe uses more than 4 controversial ingredients
We also went out and researched what the ideal diet for a cat truly is, using peer-reviewed studies and veterinarian experts.
You can find that below, under the section "What Cats Really Want To Eat".
Using that information, we rated each food to see how it stacked up to the "ideal feline diet".
Each of the data points we collected works together to form a star rating on a 0-5 star scale (including half points).
- If the food’s first ingredient is meat, it gets 1 point.
- If the food does not use unnamed meat ingredients (“meat by-products”), it gets 1 point.
- If the food has an above average protein level on a dry-matter basis, compared to all other foods in the database, it gets 1 point. If it has an average amount, it gets .5 points.
- If the recipe contains fewer than 4 controversial ingredients (not necessarily bad ingredients), it gets 1 point. If it contains exactly 4 it gets .5 points.
- The final available point is a discretionary point that we award based on things like carbohydrate content, inclusion of probiotics and vitamins, and other points, and is our judgement call on a food’s quality and biological appropriateness for your cat.
This is a fair, transparent system that allows us to compare every single food.
This is the information we use when we come up with our "top food" recommendations.
This is not random. This is not subjective. No company pays us anything to get on this list.
(We receive a small affiliate commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase through any of our links, but it is a flat rate...we don't get paid more for recommending expensive products!)
All of the foods listed above are rated 5 out of 5 stars in our database.
Only 7.5% of foods on our list got a perfect 5/5 score.
And honestly, we'll be going through it again and knocking a point off here and there, since we continue to gather important information...so the final "club" of 5/5 foods will grow even smaller.
37% of foods scored 2.5 stars or lower.
And remember, if we are hoping to provide you with the option that is closest to the "ideal feline diet", even 4 star foods are missing out on at least one important category (low protein, controversial ingredients, etc.).
So the list we have provided you above is the absolute best of the best!
How To Choose The Best Wet Cat Food
We don't just go onto Amazon and pick the foods with the best reviews like many other sites do.
We've put hundreds of hours of research into our cat food project, because we've learned just how important nutrition is to your furry pal.
Years of eating a low quality food could, quite literally, cause your cat to die early or suffer from serious, painful illnesses.
So let's walk through a little bit more on how to actually choose the right soft food.
What Cats Really Want To Eat
There have been 2 important studies done that show exactly what cats want to eat.
One study took data from dozens of other studies and put it all together.
It found that feral or wild cats eat a diet exclusively of small animals.
Mostly rabbits, rats, mice, voles, and birds.
They found that on a calorie-basis, cats choose to eat foods that give them the following macronutrient breakdown:
- Protein: 52%
- Fat: 46%
- Carbs: 2%
Another study was done on domestic cats.
Cats were given the ability to choose between a variety of commercial cat foods.
Researchers discovered that cats "self-selected" a diet that was very similar to their wild diet:
- Protein: 52%
- Fat: 36%
- Carbs: 12%
Since they were only given the option of fairly low quality commercial foods, I think the carb numbers in this study are higher than cats really want to eat.
But one thing is clear: cats want to eat high protein, moderate-to-high fat, low carb diets.
And the best way they can do that is by eating meat (including organ meats like kidneys, livers, hearts, etc.).
High Protein / Low (No) Carbs
Whatever food you choose to feed your cat should be high protein and low carb.
As the studies above show, cats want (and need) foods that are high in protein and very low in carbs.
The problem is, most cat food (even canned ones!) on the market today is full of carbs.
Because carbs are cheaper than animal proteins.
And to keep profits high, many companies choose to fill their foods with low quality carbohydrates that are not good for your cat.
Did you know that the 6 largest pet food corporations all make over $1 BILLION per year?
Sadly, each one of them produces very low quality pet foods, according to our database.
You might come across information about how carbs aren't actually that bad for cats, and that some cats really need a low protein diet.
Interestingly, a huge chunk of this information comes from the mouth of these companies themselves!
I have read articles and even studies that got me questioning whether cats really need high protein diets.
But when I check out the author, it usually leads me back to one of the big companies that stuffs their food full of fillers.
Your cat's health starts with the food you feed him.
And it's clear that animal protein is the #1 food that will make him happy, healthy, and live a long life.
Domestic cats are pretty much the exact same biologically as their wild and feral cousins.
They have not evolved in any significant way over the last 100 years or so since commercial cat food was developed.
Therefore, what cats eat in the wild is a GREAT indicator of what they should be eating at home.
How To Read The Label
Labels can be SO hard to read!
Front Of Label Marketing Claims
First of all, the marketing mumbo-jumbo that companies are allowed to put on the front of the label is outrageous.
Did you know that if they have a food that says "Fall Feast with Chicken", it must contain only 3% chicken?
There are very few regulations surrounding pet food and pet food marketing, and even fewer people policing the industry.
So whatever you read on the front of a label, just be wary!
Make sure you check the ingredients before believing anything you read.
You should be looking for real, named meat sourced to be the top few ingredients.
That means things like "chicken", "turkey", "chicken liver", etc.
Be wary of things like "animal digest", "meat and bone meal", or anything else that doesn't specifically label which animal the ingredient comes from...unfortunately unnamed meat ingredients could be anything (including diseased animals, roadkill, euthanized pets, and in one case, even a baby circus elephant!).
After making sure that the first ingredients are meat, make sure it isn't packed with grains and other carbohydrate fillers.
Things like corn, wheat, soy, and peas are common fillers that are no good for your cat.
While pet food companies are required to list the guaranteed analysis of what nutrients are in the food, it's really hard to use this information.
You see, this data includes the moisture content of the food, making it hard to compare apples to apples.
For example, a wet food might have 82% moisture, and therefore show only 12% protein.
A dry food only has about 8% moisture, so can show 40% protein, for example.
You might think that the dry food is better based on this information.
However, if you take the moisture out of each food to truly compare nutrition levels, you'll see that the wet food is actually more protein-dense.
It's even hard to compare wet foods if they have different moisture levels!
In our database, we've done calculations that show us the "dry matter" quantity of nutrients, as well as nutrients per calorie of the food.
These are MUCH better indicators...but they're hard to come across.
If you really want to dig in, there are calculators out there that show you how to do the calculations.
However, we've done the hard work for you, and compare foods on a per calorie basis, as you can see above.
This gives a MUCH more accurate picture of each food.
Guaranteed analysis can give you a really rough idea of the food's nutrients, but if you want to TRULY know what's going on, you'll need to convert those numbers to dry-matter or caloric basis numbers.
No Artificial Preservatives or Fillers
Did you know that some popular artificial preservatives like BHA are potential carcinogens?
Meaning that prolonged use could cause cancer in your cat?
We like to see natural preservatives...things like mixed tocopherols.
If it contains an artificial chemical preservative, you can almost guarantee it's a poor quality option.
Fillers are those ingredients that are not VITAL to your cat's well being.
They're usually put in a recipe to "fill" it up.
As we discovered, cats need meat...and that's pretty much it.
So anything that's not meat can be called a filler.
Common fillers are wheat, corn, peas, soy, and a variety of thickening agents.
In small quantities, they probably won't hurt your cat.
But in the long run, these ingredients can cause serious side effects, including kidney and urinary tract diseases that can be fatal.
Some filler ingredients, like cellulose, are literally made from sawdust.
Even the whole food options like wheat and corn are hard for your cat to digest, and are not as bioavailable as meat. They are NOT good ingredients and will not deliver the nutrition your kitty needs to be fit throughout his life.
One of our biggest pet peeves is ingredient splitting.
This is when you see two very similar ingredients, but called something slightly different.
Companies do this so that they can still claim meat is the main ingredient in a food.
For example, you might see this ingredient list:
- Pea fiber
- Pea protein
In this case, chicken is the largest ingredient. There is more chicken, by weight, than anything else in the recipe.
However, in many cases, when you combine the split ingredients, you'd see that chicken falls further down the list.
If there is 1 pound of chicken, .5 pounds of peas, .5 pounds of pea fiber, and .5 pounds of pea protein, clearly peas are the top ingredient, right? That's 1 pound of chicken to 1.5 pounds of pea products.
But if companies listed these ingredients together, it would be obvious that there wasn't much chicken in here, because it wouldn't be the first ingredient.
So, when you see one ingredient come up over and over again but with different names, you can almost be sure that there's not a lot of meat in the recipe.
Why Is Wet Food Better Than Dry Food?
Dry cat food is frankly really bad for cats.
Since cats get most of their moisture from the meat they eat, they have a very low thirst drive.
If cats aren't eating a wet food full of moisture (either prey animals or canned food), then they won't be getting enough moisture from their food.
And they won't be drinking enough from their water bowl to make up for it.
This leads to chronic dehydration, and can lead to painful and deadly kidney and urinary tract diseases like FLUTD.
This is what Dr. Jennifer Coates, DVM, had to say about why wet is better than dry:
“Wet food is often the best option for cats for two main reasons. First of all, wet food has a much higher water content than does dry. When cats get a lot of water with their food, it’s easier for them to stay well-hydrated. This is especially important when a cat’s kidneys are not functioning well, since the kidneys are responsible for preventing excessive water loss through the urine. Secondly, wet food tends to have a lower carbohydrate and higher protein content in comparison to dry food. This more closely mimics the natural feline diet and may help prevent and/or manage common diseases like obesity and diabetes.”
Are By-Products Bad?
Considering high-quality meats are readily available, and that many companies use them, you have to wonder why by-products are used at all.
There are only two real options here:
- They're better for cats
- They're cheaper for manufacturers
We only recommend the best and most biologically appropriate foods at Catological.
So if by-products are good for cats, then surely we'd be on board!
But by-products are basically everything that's left over from an animal after the "prime" cuts of meat have been removed for human consumption.
That means there's usually just a carcass left, with things like beaks, feathers, less desirable organs, bones, and the like.
While cats in the wild would eat some of these things as part of the prey animal they caught, the by-products would be only a small part of their meal.
Cats want organ meat and then muscle meat and some bones.
So, they don't seem to be better for cats, since they're missing many of the important parts that cats love, and won't have all the nutrients they need.
Oh, and they're often rendered beyond the point of recognition, which means they likely go through multiple heating cycles and get mixed in with all manner of other less than amazing ingredients.
OK, so by-products are clearly not added because they're the best option for cats.
I think it's safe to say that they're only included because they're cheaper for manufacturers.
You've been to the grocery store recently, right? Nice cuts of meat aren't cheap!
But a carcass that's been stripped of all the nice cuts of meat is NOT going to cost the same as a chicken breast, pound for pound.
So manufacturers use by-products to boost the protein of their foods on the cheap.
And once a company is using by-products to save a buck, they often use other low quality ingredients to boost their profits even more.
It's for this reason that we do not like to see by-products in any cat food.
If you've read all of this without choosing a food, rest assured that all of our top picks on this page are by-product free, have little to no fillers, and are packed with animal protein and organ meats.
Click here to jump back up the page to see our reviews again.
Last Updated on